Keyboard shortcuts

Press ← or → to navigate between chapters

Press S or / to search in the book

Press ? to show this help

Press Esc to hide this help

Using AI for Justice

July 2026 was a wild time to be doom scrolling in India. Thy precious is no different. On 24th of July when Poland was busy celebrating Police Day, thy precious came across this gentleman:

police threatening protestor
Snap taken from Amit Kilhor's YouTube short.

Asking for the right information

One would agree that to threaten citizens with fake NDPS cases is a disgrace to the uniform. Times of India’s article[1] mentioned that the constable shown in video clip “attached to the Central Control Room till the inquiry is over” as of 24th July 2026 itself. Remember this.

We walk over to an AI chatbot of choice and punch in a few important keywords.

You are an advocate with 10 years of experience 
in criminal cases dealing with the police.
Given the following case, give suggestion on 
what can be asked in RTI such that information is 
not denied or can later be acted upon as a legal strategy.  
- <description 1 of incident> 
- <description 2 of incident>
. 
.

Regardless of how good or bad the AI model is, do understand that it is NOT a replacement of actual advocates. Or developers. Or CA. It’s a tool to get your job done faster if you know what you’re doing. Thy precious pays his advocate for consultancy in civil cases he doesn’t want to appear party in person for.
First line of the prompt is to provide the right context for the model to start working on. Instead of randomly trying to figure out the output, the model now has a much narrower scope of decisions to make.
“Sounds a lot like black magic to me. You just tell it to be someone and the results somehow are better?” Good question. I really wish I could give you a concrete answer. But given claude is still busy uploading passwords and secrets[2] as of November 2026 to github, I think it’s fair to say everything from SKILLS.md to MCP servers are just suggestions and not commands for the compute hungry AI models. Might as well just do things the popular way.

RTI application
Given enough context, the AI model was able to stitch together the right sections from BNSS/CrPC that's relevant to detention of said people.

Information asked in (6) about departmental inquiry and (7) about complaints received is crucial. Remember this too.

RTI - Sharing reel with Mumbai Police

Social media has trained us to immediately share interesting reels with people who might find it to be very relevant. Have a look at “Using RTI the right way”[3] to learn more.
Given that we demanded a response over email and that the origin of RTI is in West Bengal, they would be responding with something in English, right? RIGHT?!

something in Marathi
I am Bihari Tom Cruise. I was not prepared for this yorker by PIO. Good one.

In the year of our lord 2026, the department responded with a language I can't speak let alone read. That's not going to be a problem tho. We just upload the said pdf file and ask for a translated version in English. What I want to draw your attention to is the (translated) response to the following:
Point No. 01: Since the requested 
information is of a personal nature, 
it cannot be provided under Section 8(1)(j) 

Point No. 02: In connection with the requested 
information, no such person was taken into custody 
by the Sion Police Station. Therefore, the requested 
information is not available in the records of Sion Police Station.

Point No. 04: The concerned person was neither 
taken into custody nor arrested by the Sion Police Station.

Point No. 06: Upon verification of the available records 
of Sion Police Station, no information regarding the said 
matter is available in the police station records.

Point No. 07: No complaint has been received/registered 
with Sion Police Station regarding the conduct of the concerned 
police personnel in the said incident. Therefore, the requested 
information is not available in the records of Sion Police Station.

Observation from the response

So at this point although the PIO has refused to reveal identity of the personnel, they have verified that he was attached with Sion Police Station. Also that people were never produced at the police station after being detained. Mind you that detention begins the moment freedom of movement is restricted. So even if they were let go - the very fact that they were kept in the police vehicle establishes a detention. Which is why the police can’t just arrest someone and produce them in front of the magistrate whenever they like. The 24hrs rule to reproduce the arrested person begins clicking the moment police restricts his freedom of movement - not when they reach the station after 5 hrs of driving around.

The response to (6) is that no departmental inquiry is conducted because, as given in (7), no complaint was registered. Well that’s an easy problem to solve buddy.

Formal complaint

Before I get to this part I want you to go back to Times of India article[1]. Didn’t they mention on 24/07/2026 that a departmental inquiry is being conducted? And here we are with official response from Mumbai Police on 13/08/2026 that in fact no such inquiry is being conducted because no such complaint was received despite a million eyeballs on his video alone. Talk about having bystander effect. I shall ask the Ministry of Home Affairs to let the Police have some time to scroll through social media. Maybe they will find something to take suo motto cognizance of.

Complain to Mumbai Police Commissionerate
So I provide the details. And then followed up for a report. And then kept following up.

So now they have a formal complaint. We are not done here. We will pursue this further and take it up with the DCP (Zone 4) of Mumbai.

Everything wrong with First Appeal

I filed for a first appeal that was sent through email on 7th September and waited. After much following up, I received a notice for it. Guess which language it was in.

Yes. And the cherry on top was that they asked me to appear in person on 28th September 2026. As much as thy precious wants meetings to be emails, this is one place that can do well with more team calls. I let them know on 27th that I will be available online. They obviously pretend to not see it and send me another notice for an apperance on 12th October 2026.
And what surprise. At the scheduled time of 4pm, there was no one to accept the invite for the first appeal. India’s Financial Capital failed to conduct a gmeet. After hours of waiting I get an email response from DCP office.

Weird People in Mumbai
I get a voice call from Govind, guy from DCP office, and then he mentions the DCP and I would connect on whatsapp call. And then he proceeds to block me on whatsapp. Genius Govind. Did you not realise I already have an audio recording?

A bogus meeting link is sent for next day at 7:30 AM. After 3 hours of no show, the DCP office rage baits like no other. Obviously that is topped off with yet another meet link with no details about time. Those meetings did not happen anyway.

On 16th October 2026 the guy from DCP office unblocks me. What a gentleman after an email was sent with audio recording and screenshot. I ask directly about his behaviour and he suggests everything will be answered by the DCP on 28th October 2026. Mind you this exceeds the 45 day limit considering the first appeal email is dated 7th September 2026. Thy precious is anyway more than happy to talk.

Result of First Appeal

Call with DCP Z4
Thy precious finally explains that a complaint indeed was sent and as such a departmental inquiry should happen. We disagreed on point (1) but he did help with (6) and (7) which is by far the most important.

Stop looking at alt of images and get a hobby
India Post had the common sense to translate Marathi to English for audience in West Bengal. The people who respond to that RTI however seem to have fun. Kasa Kai Bhau?

After 3 months of cat and mouse, Mumbai Police admits to having received complaint and officially conducts a departmental inquiry. There should be a punishment in proportion to crime.

Conclusion

Educate yourself and learn to pick a fight. Always punch up. And please learn to read Marathi when dealing with Mumbai police.
I will post an update when I get a copy of departmental inquiry report. See you around, reader.

TL;DR

Thy precious still had tokens to spare for the lazy folks. Here is an AI summary that makes clickbait of using AI feel a little more justified.

References

1. Times of India article on the incident (24/10/2026)
2. Claude uploads passwords and secrets
3. Using RTI the right way